Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Florida Construction Lawyer
Schedule a Case Analysis
Quick Contact Form

When the Schedule Becomes Evidence: CPM Scheduling in Florida Delay Disputes

Critical Path Method

Every construction project has a schedule. Far fewer have a schedule that holds up once a dispute begins. When a Florida project finishes late and the finger-pointing starts, the question is rarely whether a delay happened. The real question is whether that delay actually pushed back the completion date, and who should bear the cost. In many serious delay disputes, the answer is found in the Critical Path Method (CPM) schedule.

What the Critical Path Actually Shows

A CPM schedule breaks a project into individual activities, assigns each one a duration, and links them in the order they must happen. Footings cannot be poured until the piling is complete. Paving cannot start until the drainage is in. Once those relationships are mapped, one chain of activities emerges as the longest path through the project. That chain is the critical path, and a slip along it generally moves the finish date.

Activities that are not on the critical path have float, meaning they can slide for a time without affecting completion. That distinction carries real weight in a dispute. A three-week holdup on a non-critical task may be frustrating, but it may not support a claim for extra time or money. A three-day holdup on a critical activity can.

How Florida Public Contracts Treat CPM

On Florida Department of Transportation projects, detailed CPM requirements come from a special provision, SP0080302A, which FDOT uses when the District Construction Engineer authorizes CPM scheduling. Section 8-3.2 of that provision defines the critical path as the longest logical path through the remaining activities, resulting in the earliest calculated completion date, and bars float suppression techniques from being used to force the schedule into multiple longest paths. Each monthly update must state whether the project is ahead of or behind schedule and by how many calendar days, and must describe any change to the critical path. If the job is behind, the contractor must provide a recovery plan or connect the slippage to a request for additional Contract Time.

Private owners and local agencies often write comparable requirements into their own contracts. When a dispute moves to mediation, arbitration, or litigation, scheduling experts typically rely on the CPM schedule and its updates to perform forensic analyses, such as a time impact analysis or a collapsed as-built analysis. Those findings frequently shape whether a contractor receives an extension, whether an owner can assess liquidated damages, and how concurrent delays are divided.

Where CPM-Based Claims Fall Apart

A schedule is only as persuasive as the information behind it. Delay claims often lose strength because of avoidable problems, including:

  • Baseline schedules that were never formally accepted by the owner
  • Monthly updates that were skipped, submitted late, or unsupported by field records
  • Logic changes made without a documented explanation, which invite accusations of manipulation
  • No records connecting a specific event to a specific critical activity
  • Disagreements over who owns the float when the contract says nothing

Each of these gives the opposing side an opening to attack the analysis or argue that the delay was never critical in the first place.

Contact Us Today

Is your project schedule telling the story you need it to tell? If a delay dispute is starting to take shape, the best time to review your CPM schedule and updates is before a claim is denied, not after.

Our Florida delay claim attorneys at Linkhorst Law Firm work with contractors, subcontractors, and owners to analyze schedules, build delay and impact claims, and defend against them. We know how to turn critical path data into arguments that stand up. Call us at 561-626-8880 or complete our online form to schedule a consultation.

Source:

https://www.fdot.gov/specifications/special-provisions

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn